Pirates Fire Derek Shelton: What Happens Now?

Photo by: Joshua Peacock on Unsplash

Derek Shelton Out as Pirates Manager: What’s Next for Pittsburgh?

On May 8, 2025, after years of abysmal baseball and mismanagement, the Pittsburgh Pirates have officially parted ways with Manager Derek Shelton. Bench coach Don Kelly will take over managerial duties as the team tries to dig itself out of an ugly 12–26 hole.

"Was Shelton the problem in Pittsburgh?"

This move was a long time coming, but will it actually spark change in the Steel City?

In the short term... maybe. A managerial shake-up can light a fire under a struggling squad, and we might see a bounce-back series or two. But in the long run? Not a chance.

The Real Issue Isn’t the Dugout

Don’t get me wrong, Derek Shelton was a disaster. He had no business managing a big-league club. But firing the skipper doesn't fix what’s broken in this organization.

"This club won't win a meaningful game until: 1) The team is sold, or 2) They spend real money on a legit big-league bat."

The Pirates spend $20 million a year like it’s lunch money, and it's always on rental pitchers they ship off by the trade deadline: Rich Hill, Aroldis Chapman, Andrew Heaney... the list goes on.

Imagine instead using that same money to buy two real bats to support a pitching staff that, when healthy, could be one of the best in baseball.

What’s Next for the Pirates?

This is a step in the right direction. But unless it’s the first of multiple serious moves, nothing changes.

Paul Skenes is likely counting down the days until he can leave, and Pittsburgh’s small contention window is now. The clock is ticking... and if Bob Nutting doesn’t start spending, they’ll waste another generational pitcher just like they did with Gerrit Cole.

"Maybe, just maybe, with a consistent lineup and someone who can manage a staff, things could turn around."

A Final Thought

This post is by no means saying that Don Kelly can't be a good manager or turn things around for the Buccos, I genuinely hope he does. But after years of malpractice and mismanagement, it’s hard to hold onto hope in an organization that’s consistently let its fanbase down.

"Pittsburgh deserves a winner. The fans have waited long enough."

What do you think about Shelton’s firing? Drop your thoughts in the comments below.

View All MLB Posts →